Next Post: Reader Mailbag: Travel Thoughts
Ten Big Mistakes #8: Credit Card as Emergency Fund 23comments
Along my financial journey in life, I made a great number of mistakes. In this ten part series which runs from July 19 to July 30, I’m going to focus on ten of my worst mistakes and the difficulties and successes I’ve had in overcoming those mistakes.
I treated my credit card as my emergency fund.
In late 2004, the brakes failed (in a nearly catastrophic fashion) on my 1997 Ford F150. For whatever reason, the brake cylinders chose to collapse as I was attempting to stop at a stoplight. I nearly caused a very large accident, but I managed to get stopped after swerving into another lane and running a red light.
The repair bill was pretty significant – about $300 more than I currently had in my checking account. I remember standing there flipping through the four or five credit cards I had at the time, trying to figure out which one had enough available credit to cover that bill.
Personal finance 101 would have kept me out of this situation, but I didn’t have enough sense to have planned a bit for this brake problem. Instead, I believed that having some credit available on a credit card was just as good as an emergency fund.
That’s just horrible, horrible planning. Here’s why.
Let’s say, on average, I have a major emergency that costs $1,000 once a year in my life. A car breaks down. A job is lost. A family member is ill and you need a plane ticket. There are countless emergencies that can happen in life, so I’m just using that $1,000 once a year emergency as an example.
If you sock away $20 a week into a savings account earning 1% interest, you’ll have that $1,000 once a year when you need it. The brakes aren’t a concern, nor is that emergency flight you have to take. Plus, you’ll earn a small amount of interest on that money – $5 to $10.
If you just spend that $20 a week on something unnecessary – and that’s what you will spend it on, because almost everyone has $20 worth of fat in their weekly budget – when the emergency comes, you’re putting that $1,000 on a credit card. At that point, you’re now making $80 a month payments on that credit card instead of socking it away. Even worse, you’re paying 20% interest or so on that credit card, meaning that over the course of the year, you’ll have to make two or three extra $80 payments just to cover the interest. And while you’re making those $80 payments, you’re not socking away $20 a week for the next emergency, so when that next one hits, you repeat the cycle. You’re giving away $200 a year to the credit card companies and forgoing some savings account interest as well.
We’re not even talking about the extra risks of relying on credit cards. What happens if the emergency hits and you’ve already got a hefty balance on your cards? What if the bank lowers your credit limit and then suddenly your transmission falls apart?
None of these risks – and countless others – apply if you simply have a cash emergency fund.0
My first mistake was not having a cash emergency fund, of course. This put me up for all kinds of risks, ones that came to a head with my own financial meltdown in early 2006 when I could no longer pay my bills.
The second mistake, tied directly into this mess, was carrying a balance on my credit cards. Credit cards are a great tool, but they’re really only useful if you don’t carry a balance forward from month to month on them. If you start carrying a balance, you’re going to pay dearly for that balance in the form of very, very high interest rates.
Add the two together and you’re running on pure borrowed time, hoping that you don’t ever have more than one or two emergencies at once. Because when that happens, you’re going to find yourself in a bad place, with damaged credit, banks harassing you for their money, and a big helping of added stress in your life.
How can you avoid this trap?
The answers are really found in the mistakes I mentioned above.
First, don’t carry a credit card balance. I think credit cards are a fine tool to have if you can use them responsibly, and responsible credit card use means never carrying a balance. How do you do that? Never put anything on that card that you don’t have the money in your checking or savings account to cover.
Second, start building a cash emergency fund. The easiest way to do that is to set up an automatic savings plan. Open a savings account at a particular bank of your choice, then set up an automatic transfer from your checking account to that savings account. $20 a week is a healthy place to start because after a year, you’ll have $1,040 in your account (plus some more thanks to interest). Use that cash when something unexpected gobsmacks you.
The biggest thing, though, is to recognize that emergencies happen – and they happen more often than most people think. Our minds do a fantastic job of making our crazy disorderly lives seem pleasant and ordered. The biggest crisis in the world seems like nothing more than a speed bump after a little bit of time. Allowing yourself to be comforted by this and thus using that comfort as a reason not to build an emergency fund is one of the biggest personal finance mistakes that people make.
@Vicky,
if you really can’t put money aside for the emergency fund, perhaps it’d be better to make smaller payments on the CC (if you aren’t making minimum payments, that is) and save the extra for the EF. Yes, you’ll be paying more in interest. But if you can’t really break this cycle…
Otherwise, I’d try hard to save a bit every week/month — you can pay yourself first, automate the transfer of a certain amount into savings, etc. It doesn’t have to be $1000 at once! Can you save $50? $ 100? Start *somewhere*.
Vicky–start building the emergency fund BEFORE you get them all paid off. Get that $20 deducted from your paycheck into a savings account FIRST, then pay off the credit card bills aggressively. It seems counter-intuitive to have money in savings when you’re playing 20% interest, but doing so will have you 20% interest in the future when the next something happens. It’s the only way to break the cycle without a long streak of good luck.
Solid advice, Trent. The only thing I’d add is make sure the “emergency” you’re pulling from your emergency fund for is actually an emergency and not just a want or opportunity.
I switched to “cash basis” a few years ago, meaning I use my debit card for 99% of purchases and my credit card only for travel bookings, vet bills, and car repairs.
I don’t consider any of those categories to be “emergencies,” though. Car maintenance and pet health care are recurring, predictable expenses, and travel has always been optional.
I send payment in full to the credit card as soon as I use it – easy since I have electronic bill pay. IF I choose to use the card for something that’s a pure “want,” I have to add payment in full into my next pay period’s budget. Since I already have a line item for debt repayment and not much wiggle room, those “wants” have to pass a serious test.
I also have automatic transfer of $50 per pay period from checking to savings. I am letting this build up with the goal of having six months’ fixed expenses on hand.
I can attest that – after an adjustment period – this has been a remarkably stress-free way to handle funding for expenses that aren’t fixed.
The real keys are to keep my paws off my savings, and my eye on my budget.
My hubby and I are working to pay down credit card debt and getting an emergency fund. But, he lost his job and took one making less money. Our savings dwindled down to only a couple hundred dollars. And, lo and behold, his 1997 F150 had the brakes go out completely. They locked up so bad and put deep grooves in the driveway trying to move the truck. Unfortunately, $800 had to go on credit cards. We hated to do it, but didn’t see another choice! Hopefully we can buckle down and build the savings back up before something happens again! This emergency really made us realize how far we’ve fallen since he lost his job. I can’t wait until we’re out of this hole. One step at a time!
Very sage advice!
You might want to consider taking on a part-time job temporarily to build up your emergency fund. I did that once where I worked on Saturday shift at the local motel and put all that money into a savings account. After 4 months, I had enough and quit the job. It is not so bad to spend that extra day a week working if you know there is an end date.
I do use credit cards for emergencies but only carry a balance on them very rarely, for example when moving countries (yes I’ve done that quite often). The balances get paid off quite fast. And we have plenty of savings and other sources of cheaper loans to pay off the credit cards. So this really depends on how disciplined you are and how much money you have.
Most Americans use the CC as a emergency fund. big mistake.
I’ve been working on an emergency fund monthly now for a while, hoping to contribute more when my CC debt is gone (scheduled for about 1 year from now). But will I ever be able to take that emergency money and spend it? In retirement perhaps? I’d hate to think that I worked for money I’m never going to use.
I don’t use my credit card as my only source of an emergency, but I keep all but about $100-$200 cash in checking, the rest in savings, so If I were in an emergency and couldn’t access my bank’s ATM I would just use my CC and pay it off in full.
I also like the idea of having a one month float so that I may be able to make it up with my paychecks without even having to tap into my savings. I also like the %1 cash back so I use my CC for everything unless there’s a charge to use it or it’s not accepted. If I were able to pay my mortgage with a CC, I would!
couldn’t agree more! I remember when I got my first cavity a few years back (my one & only) — I was griping to my mom about having to pay $100 to get it filled. And she says “well, that’s what you have savings for, right?” Too true. She taught me to always have a hefty savings account. When I first started banking, I also pretended (in my checkbook register) like $100 of my bank account didn’t exist so that I would always have a cushion against an out-of-the-blue expense. These two things have saved my butt more than I care to think about.
Like #11, lmoot, I do put these expenses on the credit card. And then I pay them off at the end of the month, and often with the paycheck that just came in. So it is fine to put these expenses on credit card . . . as long as you make sure you can pay them off.
This used to be us entirely, and thankfully we are planning better now.
However, we always seems to have more emergencies than we can save for, (June $1200 daughter’s oral surgery not covered by insurance, July $1400 car repair after $700 new tires the month before, etc.) So… although we cleared the credit cards with a refinance, and had an emergency fund, it is consistently slipping downward and I am truly worried about slipping back.
The hardest thing to do for me was to build my emergency fund. It took me so long to get out of debt, I just couldn’t believe that I was supposed to have “extra” money.
Regardless, I finally did it–and the sense of security it provides is immeasurable.
And of course, it is a cash emergency fund
“This put me up for all kinds of risks, ones that came to a head with my own financial meltdown in early 2006 when I could no longer pay my bills.”
Your debt recovery story is a mystery: amount owing, repayment schedule, source of funds, occupation, etc.
It’s not unlike Lost.
@15: It is not that much of a mystery, though. I recall a few posts about the issue… I think he owed about 20K on CC debt plus student loans, and he did raid his retirement funds to pay down debt on top of some money he got from selling Stuff.
Lost, on the other hand…
to #10, Paul: you will spend your emergency fund money . . . when you have an emergency. And then you’ll save back up. The money is there to keep you from going into debt. And, realistically, unless we schedule our own death, we’re going to die with some money left unspent. Is it really a big deal to save up a couple thousand in the bank to save you just as much in interest payments on the credit card? I’d much rather pay myself back than be paying extra money to some company.
to #13, Kerry: In some personal finance circles, things like new tires, car maintenance, and braces on the kids aren’t considered emergencies. Those are all plannable things. If you own a car, some say, you should set aside money in a separate account purely to pay for issues that arise with the car. Emergencies are things like “crap, I have to pay my insurance deductible because a wind storm blew a huge branch onto my car,” or “oh, no, kid to the ER because of a sports injury.” I save all my money in one savings account . . . but if I had problems with having enough emergency fund, I would probably do some break-out accounts to help out and encourage me to save more. For you, it might be worth it to take another look at cash flow versus expenses and figure out how to make the gap bigger so that you can be putting more into savings.
The advantage of having $ routinely & automatically put into your emergency savings is that, when you do have an emergency & do have to spend the account down, you’re automatically replenishing it beginning the following month. Yes, the balance will drop temporarily, but you’ve already got a plan in place to build it back. What’s more, assuming you do have the cash set aside when you die (#10, Paul) – that may be what helps your family pay funeral expenses – because although each of us know we (& our family members) will die, I know few people who have money set aside for that purpose. Locally we have a LOT of fund raisers going on all the time for families who can’t afford a funeral.
I don’t look at credit cards the way most people do I guess. I’m comfortable having credit cards as part of my emergency strategy. The first and last part. Small immediate emergencies go on the card, it gets paid at the end of the month. Which smooths out things because I have at least a paycheck to handle it. Also for the last resort of emergencies. If I drain all my cash, and my 4-month emergency fund, and I still need more. I would put it on the card. Its not inherently bad, By using credit cards as the bottom of my emergency fund I effectively have a 14 month emergency fund. Sure my emergency fund will continue to grow, but I’d like to know in the mean time that I can handle anything.
I have to say, I did the opposite on this. When I was carrying credit card balances, I chose to pay them down aggressively rather than build an emergency fund, and use them as the emergency fund so that I could reduce the interest in a hurry. The key, though, is that I’m a frugal person (long story as to how I got the debt)and I was putting pretty much all disposable income toward credit card debt and not running them back up.
Different strategies sometimes work. The danger, though, is that it’s easier to spend on a credit card than with cash, and an “emergency” can be on a sliding scale, depending on whether you’re taking it out of savings or putting it on a card.
This is by far my favorite of the ‘10 big mistakes’ columns, because it really is the easiest trap to fall into.
It really is hard for me to pull money out of savings in an emergency, even when that’s what the money is for. In the past I’ve actually been tempted to carry a balance on a CC and try to aggressively pay it down (even though it’s a really quick way to accidentally start building CC debt back up)
I’m in the camp with Chacah 1 (#4) and Leah (#17). Car repair and maintenance is not what I call an emergency. I budget for car repair and maintenance monthly. An emergency for me would be an interruption in income due to unemployment, natural disaster, illness, etc. That’s what the six month’s living expenses in my emergency fund is for. But I agree with Trent that having extra cash, no matter what you call it, to deal with expenses that exceed monthly cash flow is better than using the card.
Thank you Marta.
So, “I could no longer pay my bills” means funds were available but they needed to be moved from an investment account to a deposit account.
Some meltdown.
Leave a reply

My new book, The Simple Dollar: How One Man Wiped Out His Debts and Achieved the Life of His Dreams, is available in bookstores now! Check out some of the 






Well.
This one hits home. I’ve been using credit cards as emergency money for years. I usually spend $3-4K a year on credit cards, and the whole year paying it off, always playing catch up.
I had actually just had all them down to a zero balance… but then I had to fumigate my house for termites and my dog broke his toe and my uncle died and … well…
Back to the credit cards…. It seems when I just get them all paid off and TRY to build the emergency fund, something comes up where I end up HAVING to use them again. It’s a frustrating cycle I’m not sure how to break.