Best Home Warranty Companies in California

Finding the best home warranty providers in California is easier than you think. Unlike some states, California has regulations in place that require home warranty providers be licensed. With policy and regulations always on the move, you need to be aware of which warranty services can provide you with the best warranty  to get the best deal and service.

The best home warranty providers do more than offer you maximum protection for your major home appliances and systems. They also offer peace of mind and a level of customer-centric professionalism that’s hard to beat.

Cinch Home Services
Home ServicesLearn More
America's First Choice Home Club
855-415-7532Learn More
First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty
877-294-4074Learn More
Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty
800-816-1053Learn More

The 5 best home warranty companies of 2019


Premiums Deductible EDOC
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty $399 to $599 $85 30 days
American Home Shield $420 to $720 $75 to $125 30 days
First American Home Warranty $300 to $534 $75 30 days
Home Service Club Starts at $400 $65 to $125 30 days
HomeServe $444 to $636 $75 to $125 30 days

The 5 best home warranty companies of 2019

2-10 Home Buyers Warranty — Best for whole house protection

Established in 1983, 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty has been serving homeowners, builders and realtors with home warranty services for 36 years. It is headquartered in Colorado and has a partnership with two trade organizations: the
National Home Service Contract Association and the National Association of Home Builders.

2-10 Home Buyers Warranty offers coverage for a select list of major household systems and appliances. Additionally, they also offer a comprehensive list of add-on coverage for things like attic and exhaust fans, pipe leaks, wiring, switches and outlets.

One of the things that sets this company apart is that it goes beyond standard home warranty offerings and also offers separate coverage for structural aspects of your home. This protects you if your house requires workmanship on specific load-bearing structures and systems.

American Home Shield — Best for self-customization plans

American Home Shield is a warranty provider headquartered in Tennessee. It has been providing home warranties since 1971. What began as an individual company later became part of the ServiceMaster group under the FrontDoor brand.

American Home Shield has a lot of flexibility to offer homeowners looking for coverage options. It has four different plans to choose from. Its appliances plan covers 10 different major appliances. The systems plan covers 11 major household systems. The combination plan is the most comprehensive and combines the latter two.

They also offer homeowners a way to customize their coverage needs by choosing 10 or more items from their select list of appliances and systems. That way, you can cover only those things that matter most to you.

First American Home Warranty — Best for coverage upgrades

Established in 1994 and headquartered in Santa Ana, California, First American Home Warranty is another great pick. It is primarily a nationwide company, but it does not service New York and a few other states. Call to confirm coverage is available in your area before you buy. If you want to view First American’s plans, you’ll need to use the online quote tool.

First American Home Warranty offers two main warranty plans: basic and premium. The basic plan covers select major household appliances while the premium plan includes the basics plus a select list of household systems.

If there is something missing from either plan that you want covered, be sure to check the add-on coverage plans, which include separate coverage for electric central air conditioning, additional refrigeration, pool/spa equipment and well pump.

The first class upgrade add-on coverage feature is what sets this home warranty company apart because it will cover some of the little things not otherwise covered for your specific warranty plan.

Home Service Club — Best for overall customization

Home Service Club focuses on its customers and proudly boasts that it’s one of the top five warranty provider spots in the country. It is a private company, established in 2008 and headquartered in New York. This company believes in customized plans that make sense for the homeowner. Deductibles for trade service vary depending on the level of risk that you’re willing to accept, but range from $65 to $125. The higher the deductible for trade service, the lower the risk.

Home Service Club offers homeowners two different warranty plans to choose from: standard and comprehensive coverage. The standard plan covers 18 select household items while the comprehensive plan covers 33 — everything from the standard plan, plus more. The company also offers up to 12 optional add-on plans for things like pools and spas, jetted bathtubs, the roof and more.

HomeServe — Best for variety

The London Stock Exchange is not exactly where most Americans would look for a home warranty provider, but this last one hits the spot. HomeServe has been around since 2003 in the U.S., but it began in the U.K. HomeServe is a subsidiary of HomeServe Plc., which is listed as one of the top 200 U.K. companies on the London Stock Exchange. The U.S. headquarters are situated in Connecticut and the company proudly serves over 4 million customers with 5.6 million contracts. In addition to warranty repairs and replacements, HomeServe also offers a 1-year guarantee on all warranty repairs with the exception of surge repairs, which come with a 90-day guarantee.

As for warranty plan offerings, this company offers a lot of variety. Its core plans include appliances, systems and a combination of the two. Beyond that, there is ample room for adding additional coverage to customize a plan that makes sense for you.

What is a home warranty?

A home warranty is an annual service agreement between you and a warranty provider to cover the unexpected cost of specific repairs and replacements of household items like major appliances, plumbing and HVAC. A home warranty provides assurance and peace of mind when you need it.

A home warranty differs from home insurance, which generally covers the cost of loss and damages to your home and belongings. Home insurance is a type of property insurance. A home warranty is not the same as insurance, but does complement it since it covers the cost of unexpected repairs or replacements of specific household items due to normal wear.

How should I choose the right home warranty plan?

Choosing the right home warranty plan anywhere is daunting, but that is even more true in California, where there is more regulation and fewer licensed warranty providers.

“It is of the utmost importance to homeowners that entities are licensed in the states in which they operate,” said David Moreno, co-owner of Liberty Home Guard, a rising home warranty provider.

“California requires all home warranty providers to be licensed as home protection companies with the California Department of Insurance,” Moreno said. “California residents need to be vigilant and take the extra step to ensure that whoever they plan on giving their hard-earned money to is licensed and in good standing with the state.”

This opinion comes from an objective place, as Liberty Home Guard is not licensed in the state of California, and consequently does not sell in the state of California.

The bottom line

Each home warranty provider is different. When deciding on a home warranty provider, the bottom line is this: shop around and learn as much about the home warranty provider as you can before you buy. Choosing the right warranty provider goes beyond finding a plan that fits. Your home is your domain, and the appliances and systems within your domain help it to run smoothly. Always do your research and look for a reputable home warranty company that you can trust.