Updated on 03.28.07

How To Use Morningstar To Evaluate Mutual Fund Choices

Trent Hamm

With so many mutual funds out there, companies loudly promoting their own funds, and people giving half-baked investment advice, how can we know what funds are really right for us? The best route is to take advantage of independent research, and for me, the best choice for independent research in mutual funds is Morningstar.

What is Morningstar? Morningstar is a provider of independent investment research in the United States and abroad. They provide much of this information for free at morningstar.com. Basically, you can use this site to look up independent evaluations on any mutual fund you like – and other investments, too. Morningstar is so trusted that many funds will use their ratings from Morningstar in their advertisements.

Okay, so how do I use it? Hop over to morningstar.com and enter the name of a mutual fund you want to look at. For our purposes, I’ll take a look at the Vanguard 500 (here’s the Morningstar page for that fund in a new window). The first thing you’ll see is a boatload of information about the fund – an almost overwhelming amount to a beginning investor. If you’re overwhelmed, click on the “Data Interpreter” link on the left hand menu, which will automatically explain some of the data for you. I used the “Data Interpreter” heavily when I was just getting started with funds.

Information overload! What’s really important? The biggest things to look at when evaluating a fund with Morningstar’s data is to look at the “Key Stats” box in the upper right. The big things that I look at are the Morningstar Rating (which I’ll discuss below) and the Expense Ratio (which I like to be low). I also look at the trailing returns in the Performance section, but mostly at the five year trend.

What do the stars mean? Each fund evaluated by Morningstar is given a star ranking, from one to five stars, that evaluates the fund in a nutshell. If you want to understand how these stars are generated, Morningstar provides a strong explanation of what they mean. Generally, I don’t spend much time looking at anything below three stars, but if it’s three stars or up, I’ll look at it more closely (as many conservative and index funds are given three stars).

One bad thing, though… As you start to really get into the information provided, you’ll find that some of the neat stuff you want to look at requires a premium membership. What I did was make a lengthy list of things I wanted to look at, signed up for a 14 day trial of the premium membership, looked those up, then cancelled the service. It was worthwhile information, but I simply did not want to pay that much for a service I wouldn’t use with high regularity.

In short, Morningstar is a great place to look up fundamental information about a fund that you might see in an ad or hear about from a friend. It provides the real scoop without any bias.

Loading Disqus Comments ...
Loading Facebook Comments ...
  1. breadman says:

    Are there any connections or disclaimers between Morningstar and the Mutual Fund Industry? In other words, should we recognize any conflicts of interest that might make one mutual fund more appealing than another?

  2. Gal Josefsberg says:

    I usually like to start with Google or Yahoo finance for some information. Then I move to Morningstar to get more in depth info. The Google and Yahoo pages don’t give enough information to make a buy decision, but they give enough to filter out stuff I’m not interested in.

  3. Beth says:

    Many public libraries (especially larger ones) subscribe to Morningstar for their users, so there is no charge at all to access this information. Many subscribe to the print, and some may have electronic access as well – if they do, then you may be able to access the information you want via the library’s web page, so long as you have a library card to access their subscription databases.

    Check with your local reference librarian for more information!

  4. Chaunacey says:

    I second Beth. Check with your library. I work at a middling size library, and we have subscriptions to Morningstar, Value Line and Outlook.

  5. Bill@mutualdecision says:

    I agree with your endorsement of Morningstar as a good and reliable tool. However, that was not always the case. For a while, your best investment strategy would be to sell any fund which received a 5 star rating. Morningstar revised their rating system in 2002 and the new system is something you can rely on. I suggest anyone really interested in Morningstar ratings read Professor Matt Morey’s, Pace University, papers “The Kiss of Death” and “Morningstar Mutual Fund ratings Redux.”

  6. blackhawkzone says:

    A better way to access the morningstar info is to set up a login with trowe price on their website. You dont need to set up an account or do any trading there. I have my accounts at tradeking.

    here is the info


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *