The 4 Best Florida Homeowners Insurance Companies

Fact-checked with HomeInsurance.com

Advertiser Disclosure

If you are a resident of the Sunshine State, you know all too well the trade-off between the beautiful beaches and the risk of hurricanes, floods and other natural disasters that may damage or destroy your home. It should come as no surprise that Florida has the highest home insurance rates of any state in the United States.  

As a Florida homeowner, it is critically important that your home is adequately insured. But how can you get coverage that is both adequate and affordable? 

There are a variety of important factors that will make a difference in what you’ll pay for home insurance in Florida including the physical location of the property, the age and condition of the home and the insurance provider you choose.


Find the Best Home Insurance

Enter your ZIP code below and be sure to click at least 2-3 companies to find the very best rate.

We’ve researched the top 4 homeowners insurance companies in Florida to help you find the right company and coverage for your needs.

The best 4 homeowners insurance companies in Florida

  • Florida Peninsula Insurance Company
  • State Farm
  • St. Johns Insurance
  • Universal Property & Casualty

Best overall: State Farm

State Farm is a nationwide insurance company with a long-established history of top-notch customer service and affordable rates. With agents local to each area served, you are guaranteed to get service personalized to you and your location. 

With average rates of $740 per year, a history of excellent customer service and a proven strong financial stability, State Farm is our top choice for home insurance coverage in Florida.

Best for lowest rates: Universal Property & Casualty

Despite being a subsidiary of the largest insurance provider in Florida (Universal Insurance Holdings), Universal Property & Casualty’s online presence isn’t as strong as some of the other companies that dominate the Florida home insurance market. However, it makes up for that by offering some of the lowest rates. The company’s average annual insurance premium for a home in Florida comes out to roughly $1,500. While its average rates are higher than State Farm’s, they are typically lower than most of their other competitors.

Universal prides itself on its superior customer service, and it has guaranteed assistance from a real person. During times of natural disaster or catastrophe, this promise may be harder to achieve, but Universal still allows policyholders to file claims 24/7 by rerouting them through an efficient automated system and having representatives reconnect with them.

Universal Property & Casualty may be a great choice for Floridians seeking the lowest rates. 

Best for customer service: St. John’s Insurance

St. Johns is a privately held Florida company that specializes in homeowner’s insurance products. Unlike other insurance companies that offer homeowners insurance as one of several services, St. Johns exclusively provides property coverage.

Though you can expect a high level of expertise from a company with such a specialized focus, policyholders are unable to benefit from multi-policy discounts that larger, more diversified companies can offer. However, St. Johns boasts an A rating in financial stability from Demotech, Inc., excellent customer service and competitive pricing for its policies, making St. John a top provider of Florida home insurance. Check out the products and services St. Johns has to offer by visiting the website and using the “Find an Agent” feature to consult with an agent near you

Best locally-based provider: Florida Peninsula Insurance Company

If you want a Florida-based home insurance provider, Florida Peninsula Insurance Company has become one of the state’s top contenders in the homeowners market.

Established in 2005, the company ranks among Florida’s top 10 local carriers. Experience handling hurricane claims is one of its most relevant selling points for Sunshine State property owners. Policyholders can file claims not just by phone but also online — a nice touch for a local provider — and take advantage of a robust learning center on the company website. AM Best gives Florida Peninsula an A on its Financial Strength Rating (FSR).

One potential drawback is that the company serves “just about” every Florida city , which doesn’t guarantee that coverage is available in your area.

Methodology

To determine the top 4 homeowners insurance providers in Florida, we took a look at ratings from organizations like J.D. Power, AM Best and BBB. We also considered customer reviews and average costs.

AM Best JD Power BBB
State Farm  A++ 3 out of 5 A+
Universal Property & Casualty A N/A A+
St. Johns Insurance N/A N/A N/A
Florida Peninsula Insurance Co A N/A A+

Average cost of homeowners insurance in Florida

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Florida is $2,133 , more than double the national average of $1,288, or put another way, 191% greater than the national average. 

Keep in mind that homeowners insurance rates in Florida will be heavily impacted by geographical location. Coastal areas of Florida may see higher rates than inland areas due to the increased risk of hurricane damage. 

Considerations

  • Compare comparable quotes: All quotes may not be equal, both in price and coverage. If one quote seems unusually low or unusually high, look at the coverage levels quoted to ensure they are the same. 
  • Hurricane insurance: Most coastal insurance agencies will encourage specific coverage for hurricane-related damages. Make sure those things are included if you need them. 

    If you include hurricane coverage as part of your Florida homeowners insurance, you will have a standard deductible and a hurricane deductible that is usually higher than the standard. The hurricane deductible will only apply if you file a claim for hurricane-related damage. 

  • Flood insurance: We recommend asking your insurance agent about adding flood insurance to your policy. Flood insurance does not come in a standard policy, but adding flood insurance in states like Florida is a must.  

Frequently asked questions

Is homeowners insurance mandatory in Florida?

It is not mandatory in Florida, but some mortgage lenders may require it. While homeowners insurance is not mandatory, if you’re going to live in Florida where the risk of natural disaster is high, make sure you are covered to avoid hardships. 

What is the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value?

Under a replacement cost homeowners policy, your home is covered for the amount it would cost to replace your home and home contents at current costs. Under an actual cash value policy, your home is covered for replacement cost minus depreciation. 

Will my policy cover damage from hurricanes or other natural disasters?

Most standard policies do not include coverage from hurricanes or other natural disasters. Speak with your insurance agent about adding coverage to make sure you have protection from the disasters most likely to happen in your area.