The Cheapest Renters Insurance Companies in Florida 2020

Hurricane Irma held the world transfixed as Florida’s beautiful beaches were battered by relentless rain, whipping winds and tons of flooding. The category-4 hurricane created over $50 billion worth of destruction that is still in repair today, and it is an event that remains fresh in the minds of renters and homeowners alike.

Find the Best Renters Insurance in Florida

Save money on renters insurance with our simple comparison tool.

Matching you with providers.
We found results in
Click at least 2-3 companies to find the very best rate.

    America’s top-rated renters insurance

    • Policies starting at just $5/month
    • Sign up in seconds, claims paid in minutes
    • Zero hassle, zero paperwork
    In this article

      Hail, hurricanes, flooding and high winds are all widespread in Florida. That creates a need for a different kind of renters insurance with specialized features that cover things like sinkholes, lightning and hurricanes. Florida has a weather system all its own, so renters must be diligent in ensuring maximum coverage for all types of events.

      The Florida Housing Finance Corporate reports in a new study that the number of renter households in 2017 exceeded 2.5 million. With so many renters and so many potential natural disasters, renters insurance is a necessity to protect your home and all of your belongings inside.
      Best renters insurance companies in Florida

      As tourism continues to rise, visitors are more common. It is essential to ensure your belongings are covered, as well as theirs. Renters insurance will protect your home, your belongings and any guests on the property.

      The cheapest renters insurance companies in Florida

      There are many excellent insurance options for Florida residents, and here we have the best renters insurance companies in the state:

      • Castle Key
      • Citizens
      • Peoples Trust
      • Security First
      • State Farm

      To assess each company, we examined their ratings. Both J.D. Power and the Better Business Bureau judge customer satisfaction on price, claims processing and overall customer service. AM Best uses a grading system to judge a company’s financial strength.

      J.D. Power and AM Best ratings are not available for all Florida insurance companies, but we include Demotech financial ratings where possible.

      These companies are not only the cheapest renters insurance companies but also come highly recommended by their customers.

      Rankings for cheapest renters insurance companies in Florida

      CompanyJ.D. PowerAM BestBBBDemotech
      State Farm3 out of 5A++ (Superior)A+A (Exceptional)
      Security FirstN/AN/AA+A (Exceptional)
      CitizensN/AA (Excellent)A+A (Unsurpassed)
      Peoples TrustN/AN/AN/AA (Exceptional)
      Castle Key2 out of 5B (Fair)CA (Unsurpassed)

      Best Florida renters insurance for claims service: Castle Key

      Castle Key is a specialized division of Allstate that provides renters insurance to Floridians. Allstate is already a well-respected renters insurance company, with excellent claims service and extra protections that will come in handy with Florida’s unpredictable weather. Allstate has 5 out of 5 rating from J.D. Power for how it handles claims.

      Best Florida renters insurance company for discounts: State Farm

      State Farm offers good insurance coverage in a variety of areas, which means you can save on your renters insurance by bundling it with your auto insurance and get more discounts for both kinds of insurance. State Farm helps you save if you have safety features like smoke alarms or a security system.

      Best Florida renters insurance company for private coverage: Citizens

      Citizens is available exclusively to Florida residents as a not-for-profit government organization. It is a popular solution for those who cannot find private coverage, and Citizens offers exclusive savings like discounts for homes with storm windows and shutters and homes in compliance with Florida Building Codes.

      Cheapest Florida renters insurance company: Security First

      Security First is also a Florida-based renters insurance company with unique coverage and affordable pricing. While most companies feature discounts for adults 65 and older, Security First offers discounts for those 55 and older. It also offers discounts for wind-resistant homes, similar to Citizens renter insurance. While your rates will be unique to you, Security First often offers the lowest insurance rate.

      The average cost of renters insurance in Florida

      Florida is on par with the national average cost of renters insurance, costing about $185 per year, while the national average is $181 annually.

      These are the average rates for the best Florida renters insurance companies:

      • Security First: $142
      • Citizens: $160
      • Peoples Trust: $170
      • Castle Key: $175
      • State Farm: $181

      Given the specific needs of Florida renters, companies have worked to adapt their policies for better coverage. With several services exclusive to Florida only, it helps to ensure better customer service, fast claims processing and, most importantly, greater affordability for better coverage.

      Florida renters insurance FAQ

      Renters insurance is especially prevalent in Florida, given its propensity for damaging storms. Consider extra protections based upon where you live. Areas closer to shore will need flood insurance more than someone living near Disney. Florida also experiences strong winds from frequent storms, and areas closer to shore could require more coverage than other areas. Some companies provide wind coverage, but not all. Determine how much risk you have and how much coverage you’d need to replace your belongings to find out how much insurance you need.

      Unlike other states, there are many Florida renters insurance companies that specifically cater to the changing Florida landscape. Where you live will significantly determine the kind of coverage that you need, and that, in turn, will help determine which company is right for you.

      Florida has more lawsuits than other states, so renters insurance will provide the extra protection you need. Renters insurance can also protect your belongings from the storms Florida tends to get. Also, many landlords require renters insurance, so check your lease. While your landlord’s policy covers the building, your belongings inside are not covered unless you pay for an insurance policy.

      Renters insurance only covers the individuals listed on the policy. If your roommate is not on your policy, he or she is not included. If they have coverage and you are not listed on their policy, you are not covered. Roommates should provide their own coverage.

      We welcome your feedback on this article and would love to hear about your experience with the Florida renters insurance companies we recommend. Contact us at inquiries@thesimpledollar.com with comments or questions.

      Lena Borrelli

      Contributing Writer

      Lena Borrelli is a Tampa-based freelance writer who has worked with leading industry titans, such as Morgan Stanley, Wells Fargo, and Simon Corporation. Her work has most recently been published on sites like TIME, ADT, Fiscal Tiger, Bankrate and Home Advisor, as well as many other websites and blogs around the world.