E*TRADE vs. TD Ameritrade

In the age of the internet, average investors are able use popular online stock brokerages like E*TRADE and TD Ameritrade to control and closely monitor their own investments in a way that never used to be possible. So if you’re trying to decide whether E*TRADE or TD Ameritrade is going to be the best choice for you to park your money, read on.

E*TRADE vs. TD Ameritrade: Head-to-Head Comparison

We decided to compare the fees, investment options, and usability of each service to see how E*TRADE and TDAmeritrade compare with each other. Here’s how they stack up:

Find the Best Online Stock Trading Platform

Choose the best broker and learn how to trade. It’s quick and easy.

In this article

    Disclosure: TheSimpleDollar.com has an advertising relationship with some of the offers included on this page. However, the rankings and listings of our reviews, tools and all other content are based on objective analysis. For more information, please check out our full Advertising Disclosure. The offers that appear on this site are from companies from which TheSimpleDollar.com receives compensation. All products are presented without warranty and all opinions expressed are our own.

    How Much Do They Cost?

    The biggest consideration when looking for a place to put your investment nest egg is cost. Fees and commissions can eat up tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars over the life of your investment. Even a small change in the amount taken out — as little as 1% — can result in drastic changes in your investment returns by the time you reach retirement.

    Fortunately, neither E*TRADE nor TD Ameritrade charge annual fees or inactivity fees, which is a good start. Both have outgoing transfer fees well within the industry’s norms: $60 at E*TRADE and $75 at TD Ameritrade.

    In terms of commissions, E*TRADE might be a better bet — they charge $0 per trade.

    Meanwhile, mutual fund trades cost a whopping $49.99 apiece over at TD Ameritrade, but they’re only $19.99 at E*TRADE.

    If you’re going to be trading in bulk, E*TRADE is the clear favorite on fees. Otherwise, neither has much of an edge here unless you plan on investing in a lot of mutual funds — in which case E*TRADE wins again.

    What Can You Invest In?

    When it comes to available investments, there is a difference between E*TRADE and TD Ameritrade — though admittedly it may not matter to most average investors.

    As for more complex investments, both allow for options trading. But when it comes to futures trading, E*TRADE has an edge. They have over 200 futures available to trade, compared to just 60 at TD Ameritrade. However, the latter also offers forex (foreign currency exchange) trades, while E*TRADE has not since 2015.

    So if you’re keeping track at home, TD Ameritrade has a wider range of investment options — unless you’re particularly predisposed toward futures trading, in which case E*TRADE has the edge.

    How Easy Are They To Use?

    Each brokerage service is pretty easy to use — they offer both desktop and browser-based investing platforms, as well as mobile apps for investors on the go.

    However, TD Ameritrade takes a clear advantage with its Thinkorswim trading platform — this is the same level of service that high-powered investors get. For a comparable drill-down on your stocks and other investments at E*TRADE, you’re going to have to hand over a quarter of a million dollars to invest, and you’ll need to make 30 or more trades per quarter.

    You just don’t see the same level of detail in E*TRADE’s standard platform that you do on TD Ameritrade. However, E*TRADE has the better mobile app — so if you’re going to be doing a lot of your trades from your mobile device, E*TRADE might have the edge here.

    Nicholas Pell

    Contributing Writer

    Nicholas Pell is a freelance personal finance writer specializing in student loans, consumer credit and living a champagne life on a Kool-Aid budget. In addition to The Simple Dollar, he’s written for Business Insider, Fox Business, WiseBread and MainStreet.