Roth IRAs and the Fear of Future Legislation

When people realize how incredible the deal is for a Roth IRA, they’re often in disbelief. After all, it lets you earn tax-free income in retirement. No federal income taxes, period, on money taken out of a Roth IRA when you’re at retirement age (and at a few other life opportunities, too).

Before we head too far down this road, let’s touch on what a Roth IRA is. I spelled it out in my earlier Roth IRA basics article, but here are the key things you need to know:

A Roth IRA is a type of Individual Retirement Account (that’s the IRA abbreviation, of course) that allows most individuals to save for retirement on their own with or without a 401(k) plan at their workplace. Someone working at Home Depot could start a Roth IRA, as could a janitor or a computer programmer working for the government.

The best way to think of a Roth IRA is like a special savings account. Just like a savings account, you open a Roth IRA at a financial institution. Just like a savings account, you add money to it, ideally on a regular basis. Just like a savings account, it builds up money over time.

Why is it so good?

if you are over 59 1/2 and have had the account for more than five years, there are no income taxes whatsoever on anything you take out of a Roth IRA. When you take money out of a savings account, you owe income tax on the interest. When you eventually take money out of your 401(k), you’re going to owe money on everything you take out. With a Roth? You owe no income taxes once you’re of retirement age.

There are a few restrictions, of course, but they’re very minor. It works this way for the vast majority of Americans.

When something seems this good, the healthy response is usually to doubt that good fortune. It makes complete sense to wonder when the government will close this system down.

I’ve received many emails over the years from readers who doubt whether they should put money into a Roth IRA because they’re sure that the government will shut down such a good thing.

My response? You’re missing out by not investing. The government is extremely unlikely to touch Roth IRAs and, even if they did, they would offer a parachute for those already in the accounts.

Let me explain my reasoning piece by piece.

First of all, a significant percentage of Americans have Roth IRAs. If Congress ended the program, they’d have a very large number of voters out there enraged at them. Those voters are typically middle to upper-middle class, meaning they would have resources to spend on getting new people into Congress.

I don’t think that there’s a Congressperson alive that wants to severely irritate 20% of the voters in their district by directly attacking their personal savings for retirement.

If the government ever had a financial need to do this, they would offer a parachute. They might close new Roth IRAs or future contributions, but I basically can’t conceive of them ever touching plans that are currently in place. The backlash against them would be tremendous. Congress simply doesn’t enact laws that will meet with a lot of resistance unless there are even more people that will love the new law. It’s not how Congress works.

If we are ever in a financial situation as a nation where such laws are being seriously considered, then we have far bigger problems than our Roth IRAs. There may be minor changes to the Roth IRA system in the future, but major ones would trigger so much backlash that Congress wouldn’t consider them unless there was a crisis so deep that it became sensible to do so, in which case the tax status of a Roth IRA would be a minor issue compared to the other problems going on.

In short, when a financial tool is being used by a significant portion of the population, it is extremely unlikely that the government would penalize people using that tool. They might consider shutting future investment in the account, but the backlash against doing anything to current Roth IRAs would be tremendous.

Because of that, I have no worries at all about utilizing the Roth IRA. It is a stellar retirement savings tool that helps greatly with taxes and makes planning easier.

If you’re thinking of saving for retirement, you can’t go wrong with a Roth IRA – and you shouldn’t worry too much about the government messing with it, either. If you’re worried about government interference in your Roth IRA, then you should be preparing for a much broader financial meltdown (something I don’t particularly advise, either, because I don’t believe in selling fear).

Trent Hamm
Trent Hamm
Founder of The Simple Dollar

Trent Hamm founded The Simple Dollar in 2006 after developing innovative financial strategies to get out of debt. Since then, he’s written three books (published by Simon & Schuster and Financial Times Press), contributed to Business Insider, US News & World Report, Yahoo Finance, and Lifehacker, and been featured in The New York Times, TIME, Forbes, The Guardian, and elsewhere.

Loading Disqus Comments ...